Who can the Yankees least afford to lose this year?

The Yankees, knock on wood, have seemingly done OK with injuries early on in camp. Often, when players report to spring training, there’s a deluge of injury news as injuries that occurred during the offseason come to light, such as Francisco Lindor’s wrist injury or Anthony Santander’s shoulder ailment. They’ve had very small scares thus far, such as Cam Schlittler taking a few days off of throwing a couple weeks ago, or Cody Bellinger’s back acting up over the weekend, but as of now, everyone seems to be on track.

Still, injuries happen, and Bellinger’s balky back was a good reminder that guys are going to pick up bumps and bruises. With that in mind, which Yankee would you least want to see get injured?

Of course, this is only a conversation if we exclude Aaron Judge, so let’s set aside the three-time MVP for now. Other than Judge, who do you think would be the toughest guy to see go down? He’s not fully back into action, but could it be Gerrit Cole? We haven’t gotten to see Cole in pinstripes since Game 5 of the 2024 World Series, a crushingly long time to wait and a bitter note to have left off on. Moreover, he stands to provide a huge boost once he returns; is there anyone else that could be as hard to lose?

Sure there is. Max Fried was the team’s MVP on the pitching side last year, buoying the club in Cole’s absence. The prospect of him and Cole as co-aces at the front of the rotation by mid-summer is tantalizing. There’s the aforementioned Bellinger, who was the Yankees’ second-best position player last year behind Judge, bringing all-around production at the plate, on the bases, and on defense, and now in the first year of a long-term contract. Not to mention, Cam Schlittler, whose production down the stretch was outstanding and whose continued rise should be one of the most fun storylines to follow this year, or Jazz Chisholm Jr., who might have the highest ceiling of any hitter on the Yankees not named Judge.

What do you think? Who, other than Judge, is the player you most want to see stay healthy in 2026? Let us know in the comments below.

The Yankees are off today, but we’ll still have plenty on the site to keep you busy. In the morning, we’ll start prepping for the World Baseball Classic, as Peter previews WBC Pool A. Later, Sam will celebrate Miguel Andújar, Nick continues our Yankees preview series with an analysis of Amed Rosario. Also, Andrés runs down the Braves as part of our broader MLB preview, and Madison puts out the call for this week’s mailbag.

Today’s Matchup

Off-day.